Article 92

Anticipated application to providers of very large online platforms and of very large online search engines

This Regulation shall apply to providers of very large online platforms and of very large online search engines designated pursuant to Article 33(4) from four months after the notification to the provider concerned referred to in Article 33(6) where that date is earlier than 17 February 2024.

Understanding This Article

Article 92 creates staggered implementation giving largest platforms (VLOPs/VLOSEs) earlier compliance deadline than smaller intermediaries, enabling phased regulatory rollout prioritizing systemically important platforms posing greatest risks. First Article 33 designations occurred April 25, 2023 when Commission designated 19 platforms including Meta (Facebook, Instagram), Google (Search, Shopping, Maps, YouTube, Play), Amazon, Apple (App Store), Microsoft (Bing, LinkedIn), TikTok, Twitter (now X), Wikipedia, Zalando, Alibaba AliExpress, Booking.com, Pinterest, Snapchat. Four-month implementation period meant these VLOPs/VLOSEs became subject to DSA from August 25, 2023, approximately 6 months before general February 17, 2024 application date. This anticipated application applied specifically to Section 5 Chapter III enhanced obligations (Articles 33-43) including: Article 34 systemic risk assessments identifying and analyzing risks from platform design and use, Article 35 risk mitigation measures implementing adequate systemic safeguards, Article 37 independent audits verifying compliance with enhanced obligations, Article 38 recommender system transparency and user controls, Article 39 online advertising transparency, Article 40 researcher data access, Article 41 compliance function, Article 42 enhanced transparency reporting, Article 43 supervisory fee obligations. General intermediary obligations (Articles 11-32) applied to VLOPs/VLOSEs from February 17, 2024 same as other platforms. Staggered approach served multiple policy objectives: enables Commission and DSCs to develop enforcement expertise with most sophisticated platforms before broader application, provides regulatory learning opportunity identifying implementation challenges with largest platforms before extending to thousands of smaller intermediaries, focuses limited enforcement resources on platforms with greatest user reach and systemic impact, gives largest platforms (who have most resources, technical capacity, legal expertise, compliance infrastructure) earlier deadlines, creates competitive environment where largest platforms operate under enhanced scrutiny establishing compliance standards smaller platforms can observe and emulate.

Key Points

  • DSA applies to designated VLOPs/VLOSEs 4 months after Article 33(6) notification
  • Only applicable if 4-month date earlier than February 17, 2024 general application
  • First VLOP/VLOSE designations issued April 25, 2023 (19 platforms)
  • Designated platforms subject to DSA from August 25, 2023 (6 months before general application)
  • Other intermediaries subject to DSA from February 17, 2024
  • Enables staggered implementation focusing initial enforcement on largest most systemically important platforms
  • VLOPs/VLOSEs had earlier compliance deadlines for Articles 33-43 enhanced obligations
  • Justifications: largest platforms have greatest resources enabling faster compliance, cause most significant harms warranting priority regulation, benefit from early clarity on requirements
  • Created 6-month period where VLOPs/VLOSEs operated under DSA while smaller platforms under pre-DSA regime
  • Enabled Commission and DSCs to develop enforcement expertise with most sophisticated platforms before broader application
  • Platforms designated after February 17, 2024 subject to DSA immediately upon designation (no 4-month grace period)
  • Anticipated application limited to Section 5 Chapter III (Articles 33-43) VLOP/VLOSE-specific requirements
  • General intermediary obligations (Articles 11-32) applied to VLOPs/VLOSEs from February 17, 2024 like all platforms

Practical Application

Phased Implementation Timeline and Experience: Meta designated VLOP for Facebook and Instagram April 25, 2023 per Article 33. Article 92 triggers 4-month compliance period. Meta must comply with Articles 33-43 enhanced obligations by August 25, 2023. Meta's preparation activities May-August 2023: Conduct comprehensive Article 34 systemic risk assessments examining Facebook and Instagram for systemic risks including illegal content dissemination, fundamental rights impacts (privacy, freedom of expression, non-discrimination), civic discourse and electoral process effects, mental health impacts particularly on minors, gender-based violence facilitation. Assessment identifies multiple high-priority risks requiring Article 35 mitigation. Implement Article 35 risk mitigation measures including: enhanced content moderation systems for illegal content with faster detection and removal, algorithmic modifications reducing recommendation amplification of harmful content to minors, election integrity protections limiting misinformation spread during electoral periods, transparency tools enabling users to understand content moderation decisions and algorithmic curation. Establish Article 41 independent compliance function reporting directly to Meta Board of Directors, staffed with 200+ compliance professionals, responsible for monitoring DSA compliance, conducting internal audits, reporting to Commission and Irish DSC. Contract Article 37 independent auditors (major accounting firms with technology audit capabilities) to conduct first annual audit verifying compliance with enhanced obligations (first audit due by April 25, 2024 - one year post-designation). Implement Article 40 researcher data access systems establishing application portal, review procedures, data access protocols enabling qualified researchers to access public data for DSA-related research. Publish Article 42 enhanced transparency reports documenting risk assessments, mitigation measures, content moderation volumes, recommender system functioning. August 25, 2023 Meta complies with Articles 33-43. Operates under DSA enhanced regime for 6 months before general application. Smaller competitors (platforms with 20-40 million users, below VLOP threshold) still under pre-DSA regime until February 17, 2024. Creates temporary competitive dynamic: Meta subject to stricter transparency and risk mitigation requirements while some competitors operate without same obligations. However, justified by Meta's 350+ million EU users creating far greater systemic impact than smaller platforms. Commission and Irish DSC gain 6 months experience enforcing DSA against Meta before February 17, 2024 when enforcement extends to thousands of additional intermediaries. Learning from Meta enforcement informs guidance, implementation best practices, enforcement priorities for broader application. February 17, 2024 general application begins. Smaller platforms now subject to Articles 11-32 general intermediary obligations.